Friday, November 13, 2026

A Closer Look: The Cranswick Farm exposé, animal cruelty and the meat-paradox 

In May, a scandal hit the headlines. A farm owned by Cranswick, the largest pork supplier in the United Kingdom (UK), was found to have been abusing piglets and sows.

Footage filmed by Animal Justice Project (AJP) showed farm workers beating animals, botched killings, and piglet mutilations. 

The exposé, first reported on by The Mail on Sunday, was met with outrage from many readers.

And indeed, the UK is often referred to as a nation of animal lovers. In 2022, a survey from the RSPCA revealed just that, with almost 70 percent identifying with the label. 

- Advertisement -

At the same time, just 3% of people in the Great Britain identify as vegan. In fact, a recent report from The Food Foundation found that the UK eats nearly twice as much meat as the global average. 

Against this backdrop, a number of questions arise: Can “animal welfare certified” farms be trusted? Is UK legislation protecting animals? And what kind of impact do such investigations have on UK law, commercial operations and public sentiment?

Exposé undercovers “systemic abuses”

Cranswick is the largest British-owned pig company. Alongside the over 900,000 pigs and piglets on its farms, it also raises and slaughters 59 million birds a year. 

This year, seeking to expand its operations, the giant submitted an application to establish a megafarm in Norfolk. The farm would have housed 870,000 chickens and 14,000 pigs. However, the application was rejected by the local council over environmental concerns. 

Cranswick’s Northmoor Farm in Lincolnshire, which houses 6,000 pigs, was the location of AJP’s latest pig farm investigation.

There, an undercover worker filmed behind the scenes and revealed the extent of the abuse and mistreatment. 

At the facility, pregnant sows were rammed into metal-barred cages called farrowing crates, unable to move for weeks.

Workers also subjected these pigs to “violent outbursts”. Pregnant sows were kicked in their stomachs and, after birth, slapped and hit with spades.

- Advertisement -

Within a few days of being born, piglets had their tails cut off without pain relief. This practice, known as tail-docking, was carried out on every piglet. Routine tail-docking is illegal in the UK.

Ten per cent of the babies died within weeks of birth, according to AJP. 

Animal welfare violations

Workers were also filmed killing piglets by using blunt force trauma. The piglets were grabbed by their hind legs and slammed to the ground. This is an illegal method of killing, dubbed “piglet thumping”.

At the same time, sick and injured animals were left without treatment. Pigs at the farm were found to be suffering from prolapses, open wounds and “football-sized hernias.” 

Following the discovery of the abuse, AJP filed a formal legal complaint with Trading Standards. The animal rights organization alleged multiple violations of the Welfare of Animals at the Time of Killing regulations.

AJP said the investigation highlights the “systemic abuses” ingrained in the pig industry. 

Cranswick said the footage resulted in the suspension of the team working at the farm. The giant also launched an internal investigation. 

“We have also suspended the farm from supplying any pigs until the investigation is completed,” the spokesperson said. 

However, this is not the first time that poor conditions, animal abuse, and other illegal practices have been found to be taking place at farms and slaughterhouses in the UK — and not the first time they have been recorded at Cranswick. In fact, these practices are prevalent and widespread.

Abuse found at ‘animal welfare certified’ farms

Over the years, numerous exposés have taken place at RSPCA Assured farms and Red Tractor-certified farms.

In 2024, Animal Rising conducted 60 investigations on 45 RSPCA Assured farms in England and Scotland over four months. The organization discovered animal suffering on every farm. 

Multiple RSPCA Assured regulation breaches were identified, alongside 280 breaches of legal regulations.

Later, its investigation of RSPCA Assured slaughterhouses discovered what it called “systemic cruelty.” Workers were found to be hitting and kicking animals and carrying out “inhumane slaughter.”   

Similar assaults were found to be taking place at Red Tractor-certified Tafarn Y Bugail. An undercover investigation by the animal charity Viva showed cows being “pushed, shoved and kicked in the udder.” Cows were hit, on average, 75 times per milking. 

This dairy had previously supplied “one of the largest dairy cooperatives in the UK.” 

Another AJP investigation reviewed RSPCA Assured farms associated with the British Free Range Egg Producers Association (BFREPA).

BFREPA is an organization that represents 600 egg farmers, who produce 70% of the free-range eggs in the country.

AJP found the chickens were living in filthy conditions with “widespread suffering” taking place. This included chickens being left with untreated ailments and injuries, including “bloody prolapses.” Decomposing hens were also shown littering the floor.

Elsewhere, an investigation into RSPCA-Assured poultry processors by AJP revealed what it called “excessive use of force, violence and aggression by workers,” including kicking. 

The UK’s animal welfare legislation 

The scale and severity of abuse across these farms raise questions about both the implementation and enforcement of animal welfare legislation.

In England and Wales, the law on animal welfare in farming is covered by:

However, data from The Animal Law Foundation has revealed “widespread and systemic under-enforcement” of these legal frameworks. 

Between 2022 and 2023, just 2.5% of farms were inspected, and of those 2.5%, non-compliance was found across 22%. Fewer than 1% of cases of non-compliance were prosecuted.

In February, a report from the UK’s Animal Sentience Committee (ASC) echoed these findings. 

The ASC said that despite legislative and guidelines progress on animal welfare, “an effective, structured, fair and integrated system of animal welfare surveillance and enforcement is lacking.”

Animal welfare spotlighted in parliament 

With enforcement of legislation “lacking”, AJP has launched a petition calling on the government to enforce its “piglet thumping” ban.

The organization has also called for an independent public inquiry into pig farming practices and regulatory failures. And discussion on these regulatory failures just recently made its way into Parliament.

Following the publication of the investigation, a debate on intensive farming was held in Parliament in June.

At the debate, MPs spoke about farming practices, upcoming trade deals with the US, India and the Gulf and UK farmers. Indeed, on the latter point, numerous MPs warned that improving standards should not “disadvantage” farmers. 

Adrian Ramsay, MP for Waveney Valley, said that “shocking incidents” — such as those revealed by AJP — were a “symptom” of policy and enforcement failings in the food and farming systems.

Later, Terry Jermy, MP for South West Norfolk, said that in the wake of the exposé, a “rethink” of animal welfare policy was required. “….intensive farming is a particular concern for me,” said Jermy. “It is clear that the whole regulatory system is currently completely toothless,” he added.

Ramsay also called for farrowing crates on pig farms to be “urgently reviewed,” with a clear and swift timetable for their ban.

In response, Daniel Zeichner, Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs, said that the Petitions Committee had selected a recent e-petition on the use of cages and crates for debate. “…many of us will be back here in a couple of weeks’ time to discuss those issues,” commented Zeichner.

Supermarkets suspend farm use

Beyond Parliament, after the widespread reporting on the Cranswick scandal, Red Tractor issued a statement outlining that the farm’s Red Tractor certificate had been suspended pending an independent investigation.

The not-for-profit company outlined that the farm would remain “unassured” if it was not satisfied its standards were being met.

The investigation also resulted in Asda, Morrisons, Sainsbury’s and Tesco suspending their use of the farm.

This has already had significant financial implications for the company. 

According to AJP, 48 hours after the Northmoor Farm investigation broke, Cranswick plc’s market value “plummeted by nearly £300 million,” with share prices dropping 9% in a single day.

Double standard

However, Tesco has not yet dropped the supplier, AJP said. But while supermarkets have condemned the practices found at Northmoor Farm, World Animal Protection has pointed to a “glaring double standard” when it comes to their other suppliers. 

In its commentary on the scandal, the organization highlighted that supermarkets continue to stock brands from other meat giants, such as JBS.

World Animal Protection notes that JBS is the “world’s largest factory farming company” — and one which has been “repeatedly linked to animal cruelty, environmental destruction, and deforestation.”

In April this year, Peta obtained a U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) report, which revealed details of a botched killing at a JBS slaughterhouse in Green Bay, similar to the botched killings at Cranswick.

According to the report, a cow was still conscious when an employee sawed into her neck.

At another JBS slaughterhouse, workers were found to have beaten pigs with rattle paddles and discovered other botched killings, including an instance where a pig, shackled upside down, struggled for air after having their throat slit. 

In the UK, Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Asda, and Lidl stock products sourced from JBS subsidiaries Moy Park and Pilgrim’s UK. “Inside Cranswick’s factory farms, pigs — intelligent and sensitive animals — are treated as soulless cogs in a machine,” said Annie Evans, UK Farming Campaign Delivery Manager at World Animal Protection.

“This farming model prioritizes profit over welfare, causing immense suffering. We urge supermarkets and the UK government to stop supporting factory farming and champion a transition to high-welfare, sustainable farming systems that protect animals, support farmers, and safeguard our planet,” she added. 

Public sentiment

Alongside supermarkets pulling the supplier, debates in Parliament and an internal investigation initiated by Cranswick itself, the exposé has also made waves among the general public.

Many in the comment section of The Mail on Sunday’s exclusive condemned the company and its behaviour. Some urged stores to drop the company as a supplier. Others called the findings “barbaric” and “absolutely shocking.”

Amongst those expressing outrage were commenters who pointed out the complicity of meat eaters in the abuse. “If you eat meat then you are a part of this,” wrote one commenter.

“Happening up and down the country in farms and slaughter houses and has done for years. If you don’t like it then go vegan. If you’re ok with it then just carry on eating meat,” wrote another.

Cognitive dissonance 

Indeed, with the majority of the UK regularly consuming meat and many simultaneously identifying as animal lovers, some level of cognitive dissonance — a state of discomfort when your beliefs and actions don’t align —  is happening on a significant scale. In the context of meat consumption, this is dubbed the “meat paradox.”

Researchers have found that common rationalizations to alleviate this cognitive dissonance can be divided into four categories, known as the 4Ns:

  • The belief that meat is “natural” and humans are geared up to consume it,
  • The belief most people eat meat, and therefore it’s “normal,”
  • The belief that meat is a source of vital nutrients, and so it’s “necessary,” and
  • The belief that it’s “nice” — people enjoy the taste of meat. 

Both “necessary” and “nice” stood out as the strongest rationalizations in the research.

Others rationalize their meat-eating by denying that animals used for food feel pain in order to make eating them feel harmless, or alternatively disregard animals’ positive qualities.

So, do investigations like those carried out by AJP change people’s attitudes to meat eating? 

The research is mixed

One 2021 study found that expressing “moral outrage” at factory farming allowed people to reduce their cognitive dissonance by blaming a third party.

However, a 2025 study determined that peering behind the factory farm curtain can influence behaviour change.

When participants were exposed to a picture of a pork chop paired with an image of a human stunning a pig before slaughter, this evoked what it called perpetrator (e.g., anger, disgust) and victim-oriented emotions (e.g., empathy, sadness). These emotions resulted in a greater willingness to change pork chop consumption.

However, the study also found that “hedonic motivations” (the “nice” rationalization) to eat meat remain a major barrier to change.

According to the study, campaigns should balance moral appeals with practical, “non-confrontational solutions.” This, the report said, could help to reduce defensiveness around meat eating.

Elsewhere, other researchers have echoed this, outlining that avoiding blaming others for their meat consumption can be effective in reducing their consumption. 

“Instead, approach these tricky interactions with compassion,” said academics Sarah Gradidge and Magdalena Zawisza.

According to Gradidge and Zawisza, humanizing animals by encouraging people to “view them instead as friends and not food” can also help influence behaviour. 

The path ahead

In the UK, 85% of farmed animals live on factory farms. And intensive farming, where poor conditions and animal abuse are rife, is on the rise across Europe, including in the UK. However, change could be afoot.

Sustain is one of the NGOs that provided legal testimony as part of the Cranswick megafarm consultation in Norfolk. According to the NGO, the rejection of the planning application, which it called a “landmark decision,” marks a “turning point” for industrial livestock production in the UK. 

“Local authorities are waking up to the reality of industrial farming. A damaging and extractive system of food production that poses a serious threat to human health and our country’s future, both economically and environmentally,” said Lily O’Mara, Climate Campaigner at Sustain. 

“King’s Lynn and West Norfolk Council has rightly put nature and communities first by saying no to a development that would have sent us in completely the wrong direction,” she added. And conversations have continued in Parliament.

Ban on cages

On Monday, 16th June, MPs gathered to discuss cages and crates for farmed animals after an e-petition reached over 106,759 signatures. It was the third consecutive week animal welfare issues had been debated.

At the debate, support for a ban on cages and farrowing crates was expressed by MPs from multiple parties. 

However, others pushed back, including Charlie Dewhirst, MP for Bridlington and The Wolds, who defended the use of crates for sows and argued: “If the industry continues to move in the right direction, a ban does not necessarily need to be implemented.”

At the close of the debate, the Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs said that going forward, as the government brought through proposals, they would be subjected to a full consultation. 

“We absolutely recognise that the industry will need time to adapt,” said Zeichner.  Meanwhile, Irene Campbell, MP for North Ayrshire and Arran, highlighted the urgency of the situation. 

“Next year will be the 20th anniversary of our historic Animal Welfare Act of 2006 and yet, since the UK left the EU, we have been downgraded in World Animal Protection’s animal protection index,” said Campbell.

“It is time to strengthen our animal welfare standards and to make the UK a leader in animal welfare once again. I ask that our Labour Government start the consultation on cages for hens and farrowing crates for sows. How we treat our animals reflects our values as a society, and it is time to take action now,” she added.

And for organizations like AJP, founder Claire Palmer says the fight is far from over: “This marks the start of a national, sustained campaign to expose the violent realities of pig farming in Britain. We will not be pulling any punches.” 

   

Sign up for our weekly animal newsletter

* indicates required
           
   

Stay Connected

10,752FansLike
4,498FollowersFollow
3,939SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles

Authors